10 Best Local Restaurants in Key West

Conch Republic Seafood Company is a lively beach bar with seafood, live music, and plenty of Caribbean flair that creates a welcoming and relaxing atmosphere. Fresh seafood is the main star of the menu, utilizing Caribbean and American recipes together.

The layout of the restaurant creates an inviting atmosphere, as 3 sides of it are open to the outside. The smells and live music often fill the surrounding area of the street, so simply walking by might be enough to lure you in. You'll find it located on the north side of downtown by the coast.

Two Friends Patio Restaurant is one of the oldest restaurants in town and serves breakfast, lunch, dinner, and a drink to finish off the day. The establishment dates back to 1967, though the spot it stands on served as a saloon back in 1886. When you visit today, you can see some history among the restaurant's decor.

On the menu, you'll find mostly American fare, but there's some Caribbean flair in there as well. They're generally better known for their breakfast food, with evenings being heralded for their drink selections. You can experience it for yourself right downtown on the corner of Front and Ann.

Off the Hook Grill Key West is a local seafood pub where you'll find a wide variety of different drink options alongside delicious seafood. Being a pub and a restaurant, you'll find a large bar area if you're looking for a drink, and there are proper tables and booths where you can sit and enjoy a full meal.

On the menu, you'll find some of the best seafood in town. They offer fresh fish and ceviche every day, with the actual item changing depending on what's fresh during the season. Stone crab claws are a popular favorite as well, and you'll also find duck breast prepared several different ways. You can find it by Key West Bight.

Seven Fish is a long-beloved Key West restaurant where you can enjoy a contemporary bistro with a casual and welcoming atmosphere. The dishes here are notably unpretentious, offering something that everybody can enjoy, including kids.

While they strive to offer universally appealing food, they still have a passion for quality, so you'll find that only the finest fresh ingredients are used in their daily made-from-scratch items. Seafood is particularly popular here, but you'll also find a surprisingly vast wine menu. It's all located right in the historic district.

Seaside Cafe at the Mansion is known for its positively picturesque views of the surrounding coast as well as for serving delicious food for the whole family. Just about every seat in this restaurant offers an impressive view to pair with the relaxing and upscale yet casual ambience.

When it comes to the food, you'll find a spectrum of delicious dishes like salami pizza and coconut shrimp. The dessert is especially popular, with items like Key lime pie and coconut pie. Several drinks, such as mojitos and margaritas, are available as well. It's all located on Duval Street by the southern coast in Casa Marina.

Sarabeth's Key West is a James Beard award-winning restaurant that offers exceptional seafood and grilled meats alongside breakfast and lunch foods in a historic building. The menu is designed to elevate classic American cooking, so you can expect quality, fresh ingredients whether you order a proper seared fish or a sandwich and a salad.

One of the more interesting aspects of this restaurant is that it's located in a historic building from the 19th century. The atmosphere here lets you feel as if you've stepped back into the past, yet the taste meets even the harshest contemporary standards. It's located in Old Town off Simonton.

Blackfin Bistro is an upscale, classic bistro that sports a Key West flair and offers simple and freshly sourced seafood alongside a generous drink selection. The menu is relatively small, but you'll still find something for just about everyone whether they're interested in soup, lobster rolls, or something a bit more exotic, like escargot.

The wine list is especially impressive here with an array of whites and reds on offer. You can order by the glass or get an entire bottle if you like. Wines are sourced from all over the world from destinations like Oregon, Italy, Germany, and even New Zealand. It's located around where the historic district meets Bahama Village.

Hurricane Hole Restaurant & Marina is a unique local seafood restaurant that features its own dock with easy access to thrilling watersports to enjoy. The restaurant serves seafood caught just a short distance away from the property.

At the marina, you can enjoy a wide variety of watersports whether you're looking to relax on a boat cruise or do something a bit more thrilling, like tubing. All the gear you need is available on-site, and there's room on the dock for you to arrive by boat if you like. It's located on the east side of Cow Key Channel on the east side of the island.

The Flaming Buoy Filet Co. is a popular local restaurant best known for its smoky and grilled items, but you'll find a relaxing atmosphere and vegetarian options too. The menu here offers a variety of delicious dishes, including pink shrimp, lobster mac, pan-seared yellowtail snapper, and a spicy chocolate quesadilla.

The atmosphere of this restaurant makes it easy to feel comfortable, featuring wood furnishings and an orange and yellow color scheme throughout. You can see it all for yourself in the downtown area off Eaton.