We stayed at Pepe's for one night and got the Havana experience we were looking for. It was in close walking distance to the Capitol, the Plazas, Squares and other sites the tours will take you to. But the property is in the heart of Old Havana were locals are going about their daily lives.
We always felt safe, although chose not to stay out too long after dark as the streets got pretty quiet.
Pepe was a great host and gave us great recommendations and directions, as well as arranging our transportation back to Varadero for much less than we had expected to pay.
The property is a beautiful apartment on the 5th floor, with a lovely balcony overlooking the street. The room was very clean and comfortable, and we had a private bathroom, not adjoining, but nearby. The air conditioning kept us comfortable at night, and street noise was non-existent until the morning.
Tip: if, like us, you're coming from resort areas, ensure you have your passport or a photo of it, as it is necessary for Pepe to register your stay.